Skip to content
← All comparisons

ONE PROMPT, FOUR IMAGE MODELS / 7 MIN READ /

Same prompt, four image models in Pika: text accuracy and real credit costs

We gave Nano Banana 2.1, GPT Image 2.6, Seedream 5.5 and Ideogram 4.5 the same chalkboard-sign prompt inside Pika. See each image, how each model handled the text, and what each one cost.

Four café images of a chalkboard sign reading OAT LATTE $5 beside a latte, made in Pika with four image models and labelled with credit cost

All four models spelled “OAT LATTE $5” correctly. GPT Image 2.6 and Seedream 5.5 gave the best results per credit at 3 credits each, Ideogram 4.5 copied the line most exactly, and Nano Banana 2.1 cost the most at 8 credits.

Pika offers several image models in one account. To see how they handle a short line of text inside a photo, we gave four of them the same prompt and compared the images and the credits charged.

How we ran the test

Every model got this prompt, typed exactly the same way:

A small black chalkboard sign on a wooden cafe counter next to a white cup of latte with a heart in the foam. The sign reads “OAT LATTE $5” in neat white chalk letters. Warm morning window light, shallow depth of field, realistic photo.

Setting Value
Input Text only, no reference image
Shape 16:9 (Ideogram uses pixel sizes, so we picked 2560 × 1440)
Quality and resolution Each app’s default: Nano Banana 1K, GPT Image Low at 1K, Seedream 2K, Ideogram Medium
Outputs 1 per model

We judged each image on what the prompt asked for: the exact sign text, a heart in the foam, warm morning window light and a realistic photo.

GPT Image 2.6, Seedream 5.5 and Ideogram 4.5 forms side by side with the size settings, Ideogram size menu and credit estimates outlined
Three of the forms before generating. GPT Image shows a 2–3 credit range, Seedream defaults to 2K, and Ideogram asks for a pixel size instead of a shape.

Results at a glance

Model Credits charged Sign text Heart in foam Warm window light Output size
GPT Image 2.6 (Low) 3 Correct, on three lines with added dashes Clear Strongest 1280 × 720
Seedream 5.5 (2K) 3 Correct, on two lines with a large price Yes, tulip-style lines Side light, darker room 2816 × 1584
Ideogram 4.5 (Medium) 6 Correct, on one line exactly as written Clear Soft and cool 2560 × 1440
Nano Banana 2.1 (1K) 8 Correct, on two lines Small and faint Bright 1376 × 768

No model added extra words or misspelled the sign.

Compare the signs

Close-ups of four chalkboard signs reading OAT LATTE $5, one from each image model, labelled with credit cost
Close-ups cropped from each image. The wording is right in all four; the line breaks and extras differ.

If the exact layout of your words matters, for a menu, a label or a poster, Ideogram was the only model that kept the text on one line as typed. The others chose their own line breaks, and GPT Image added decorative dashes around the price.

See each image

GPT Image 2.6 · 3 credits

A-frame chalkboard reading OAT LATTE $5 on three lines beside a latte with a heart, in golden window light with flowers and a plant
GPT Image 2.6 · quality Low · 1280 × 720. The warmest light of the four, with flowers and a plant the prompt did not ask for.

GPT Image matched the “warm morning window light” best and drew a clear heart. It turned the sign into an A-frame board and split the text over three lines. The form showed an estimate of 2–3 credits and charged 3. Low is the default quality; higher settings cost more.

Seedream 5.5 · 3 credits

Chalkboard reading OAT LATTE above a large $5 beside a latte on a dark wooden counter in side light
Seedream 5.5 · 2K · shown here at 1600 × 900 (the download is 2816 × 1584). A clean sign and sharp detail in a darker café.

Seedream gave the largest file and the cleanest sign shape for the same 3 credits as GPT Image. The light comes from the side, and the café behind is darker than “morning” suggests. Its form also showed an “Upgrade to get free Seedream 5.5 images” banner; you can close it and generate as normal.

Ideogram 4.5 · 6 credits

Framed chalkboard reading OAT LATTE $5 on one line beside a latte, with a plant and brass milk jug by a window
Ideogram 4.5 · quality Medium · shown here at 1600 × 900 (the download is 2560 × 1440). The exact one-line text, in softer, cooler light.

Ideogram wrote the line exactly as typed and drew a clear heart. The light is soft and slightly cool, so it fits “warm morning” least well, and it added small coffee stains on the counter. It costs twice as much as GPT Image or Seedream.

Nano Banana 2.1 · 8 credits

Framed chalkboard reading OAT on one line and LATTE $5 below it, beside a latte with a faint heart, espresso machine and jars behind
Nano Banana 2.1 · 1K · 1376 × 768. Bright light and a busy background; the heart in the foam is small and faint.

Nano Banana produced a believable café with an espresso machine and jars of beans. The heart was the weakest of the four, and it was the most expensive run: the form estimated 4–8 credits and charged 8.

Which model should you use?

If you want… Start with Why
The lowest cost with good light GPT Image 2.6 3 credits; warmest scene in our test
Large, sharp files for print or cropping Seedream 5.5 3 credits for a 2K image
Text laid out exactly as typed Ideogram 4.5 Kept our single line unchanged
A busy, detailed scene Nano Banana 2.1 Most background detail, at the highest cost

A practical approach: try your prompt on GPT Image or Seedream first, then switch to Ideogram if the text layout is wrong. To animate the result, see how seven video models handled a latte-art clip.

What to check before you generate

  • Read the estimate on the button. Two forms showed a range, and both charged the top of it.
  • Check quality and resolution. Each model has its own defaults, and raising them raises the cost.
  • Set the size on Ideogram. It offers pixel sizes such as 2560 × 1440 instead of a 16:9 shape.
  • Ignore upgrade banners unless you want to change your plan.

Our pricing guide lists Pika’s published cost for each model.

Limits of this test

  • One prompt and one run per model. Another prompt, or a second run, can give different results.
  • The sign text was short. Longer text, small print or other languages may separate the models more.
  • Each model ran at its default quality, so output sizes differ.
  • Credits are what our account was charged. Your quote may differ with other settings.

Common questions

Which Pika image model is best for text?

All four spelled our short sign correctly. Ideogram 4.5 was the only one that kept the words on one line exactly as typed, so start there when layout matters.

What is the cheapest image model in Pika?

In our test, GPT Image 2.6 at Low quality and Seedream 5.5 at 2K each cost 3 credits for one image.

Why did Nano Banana cost more than the others?

Its form showed a 4–8 credit estimate and charged 8 for one 1K image. That made it the most expensive of the four in this test.

Why are the image sizes different?

Each model ran at its own default. GPT Image and Nano Banana made roughly 1K images, Seedream made 2K, and Ideogram used the 2560 × 1440 size we picked.

YOUR NEXT STEP

Put it into practice.

Compare Pika's video modelsSee every model's credit costMake images in Pika